I wonder about an aspect of discomfort that a traditionally hegemonic group feels when a society shifts away from them.
Namely, when the language shifts away from them, or a number of cultural objects that don’t resonate immediately with them.
I was listening to a friend’s roommate repeatedly go “Marie Kondo is about minimalism.” “Minimalism.” “Minimalism.” “Minimalism.”
And it was like, “What if that isn’t what she’s about?”
What if it’s a more subtle root in Shintoism, and the embodiment of spirit within each object, and to have a process of recognition of your relationship to the object?
As opposed to the implications of Western minimalism which is more a distillation of things within your life, and how the things you keep have a purpose to you.
It’s interesting to see the blinded-ness of encountering a cultural Object that doesn’t inherently echo your own thoughts. Or to not recognize the language it speaks.
Sometimes it’s straightforward as a Spanish song entering an English-speaking ranking charts. It’s overt in its foreignness.
And it can be disconcerting that this thing isn’t comprehendible, or more cynically — not making enough of an effort to be comprehendible. It seems rude that it isn’t.
But it’s also a reminder that the world is more vast, more plural.
As an inverse experience, growing up ethically Asian in America. Meant that inherently nothing was speaking to me. Country music wasn’t speaking to me about me and my concerns. It was speaking someone else about their shared concerns.
Which makes something like my relationship to hip-hop interesting. Most of isn’t speaking to me. Most of it is talking about things I don’t experience. And yet I enjoy it as a musical form, as a genre, as a construction of language, as an expression to be heard. But most of it isn’t speaking to me.
And I’m okay with that. I don’t take their symbols or concerns or words as my own, and I’m ultimately a voyeur. And that’s a discussion for another day.
But I wonder if this process is particularly painful for those who are being shifted from the majority to a minority. That it’s unfamiliar and untaught. I wonder.